|
Forums >
General Industry >
let's play!!pick your least favorite picture!!!
Synthetic Shadows wrote: I totally didn't see that you'd posted! (And thank you for the critique.) I'm least wild about the high heel shot. There's possibility with the idea, but the image itself doesn't quite get to where I think you were reaching. It's missing some element of tension, I think, though how you'd convey that with feet is beyond me, so I don't know how helpful this critique actually is. Apr 14 06 12:07 pm Link thanks cheri, and cristina, name your date! Apr 14 06 12:11 pm Link Sita Mae Edwards wrote: thanks Apr 14 06 12:14 pm Link Synthetic Shadows wrote: lol if that were possible a lot of people would be in trouble Apr 14 06 12:14 pm Link This one, it look the same that the other one, don t need to have twice the same... https://img3.modelmayhem.com/060219/12/ … 6abe_m.jpg I hope you enjoy the game??!!i think it s very interesting to know what we have to improve!! Apr 14 06 10:04 pm Link This one, it look the same that the other one, don t need to have twice the same... https://img3.modelmayhem.com/060219/12/ … 6abe_m.jpg I hope you enjoy the game??!!i think it s very interesting to know what we have to improve!! Apr 14 06 10:04 pm Link  I understand the concept of the slight look away, but in this instance, you look slight....not cross-eyed, but you know, your eyes are off... and you look more like a lost puppy who wants to be adopted Apr 14 06 10:09 pm Link Apr 14 06 10:12 pm Link number one... DONT SKIP ME....ARG number 2...i believe the concept is to pick the person before you's LEAST favorite Apr 14 06 10:14 pm Link Oh gosh... Tiffany from Nashville not an easy task. In fact I would say - very, very difficult to pic one which I wouldn't like. Your portfolio is beautiful, perfectly balanced and you look stunning in every single picture. Very difficult if not impossible to choose one I don't like. But if I had to choose, it would be this one:  nothing major wrong with it, only I had to pick one, so I did. Perhaps I would mention a non easy POV which photographer chose and a little bit too serious expression - kind of like - WTF are you staring at? Either way, very hard decission  Apr 14 06 10:18 pm Link -Katrina- wrote: Katrina, for me it would have to be this one Apr 14 06 10:19 pm Link difficult choice as well..great portfolio.different.I like that! but if i have to choose one, i would go for this one, as we don t see the model (the idea is good but there is something less interresting than the others one...) https://img1.modelmayhem.com/060120/20/ … c55a_m.jpg and MarkMerek, we pick you thus i do it... good ideas aswell, good job.i would go for the second one as it s the same that the first one... https://img4.modelmayhem.com/060409/22/ … e4ad_m.jpg Apr 14 06 11:19 pm Link It always comes back to you...lol This one: https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic_id=4434d5faafd8b Too snapshotty. Apr 14 06 11:25 pm Link normal...i did the thread!, I have to play!lol this one as i don t realy understand why it s in your portfolio...it would be better in the portfolio of your dog!!!lol soory,it s just my advice...don t take it wrong! https://img4.modelmayhem.com/060413/13/ … 3ac4_m.jpg Apr 14 06 11:31 pm Link haha none taken. It is only for the dog! Apr 14 06 11:34 pm Link Ok lets join the insanity This one looks like something from a crappy test shoot, plus I'm not a fan of the multi pic gig, lose it.  I dont know what this is, a candid, home amatuer shoot, or just poorly framed with no aspect ratio considerations.  Apr 14 06 11:45 pm Link Okay, In my opinion a self portrait should show your best. So I pick your current avatar. https://www.modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic … 09045e8bb7 otherwise. https://www.modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic … 0efb02c4f4 I feel I am missing the action of the shot. Weakest shot. Apr 14 06 11:52 pm Link this one as is exactly the same...you have to choose!for me the darker one is better... https://www.modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic … 4bb148a5b7 Apr 15 06 07:51 am Link MartinCoatesIV wrote: Frankly this photo is hilarious. I love it. I agree with the comments above but it still makes me smile. Apr 15 06 02:32 pm Link What a great opportunity for some "real" constructive critique ... besides its becomming really hard to drop pics when I have new images to upload ... I think this one .... https://img2.modelmayhem.com/051102/20/ … 5563d0.jpg firstly the image dosent work so well as a thumb .. but apon biggification to fullsize it turns out to be actually really good in tonal quality ... i love the difference in colour and texture between the sheets and the models skin ... But ... whats happening in the top left hand quadrant ... the bulge looks out of place, awkward and possably in need of medical attention ... distracting ... nothing that cant be cured with a little cropping Apr 15 06 08:19 pm Link Matt the Viking - first I'd like to say amazing work. It was damn near impossible for me to pick a least favorite. I picked this one https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic_id=440b71c8e4a97 , Nice image, but it doesn't strike me nearly as much as the rest of your portfolio. Again, you have some great concepts and I love everything I see. Edited : I had a period at the end of the link, it's fixed. Apr 15 06 08:37 pm Link Thankyou Envy ... True praise from you ... Your work is outstanding .. all eyecandy of the highest level ... i guess I have to add Tennessee to my list of places to visit now ... Your link is not to my folio though ... so I cant see the wrong-un  If i have to pick one of yours while this is an awesome headshot it simply looks out of place with the rest of your work ... https://img1.modelmayhem.com/060101/23/ … 02560a.jpg ... Matt Apr 15 06 08:48 pm Link Okay, Matt! I know you had one done already but you're right before me soo.... https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic_id=4321d7ad80773 I think that is probably me least favorite, just because it seems like it has the "least" amount of character out of all your shots. Also, there's something about the lipstick that really irks me. It's not a bad picture, it just doesn't speak as loudly as most of the others do. Apr 15 06 08:59 pm Link Ok this is my least favorite. https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic_id=443f84571fc98 I would like to see it in B&W and maybe more off center to give it a little more life. Cheers. Keith Carey Apr 15 06 09:05 pm Link Keith, first off great port.  But this pic just falls by the wayside. The model gets lost in the lighting. It's almost flat on the right side in both lighting and composition. Apr 15 06 09:10 pm Link well Ransom my least fav would have to be:  Just doesn't fit with your port, It doesn't show off your obvious talent, ultimately its just not very interesting. nice work overall tho! -Rich Apr 15 06 09:25 pm Link this one... good portfolio, difficult to choose.this one qs we don t see the models. https://img1.modelmayhem.com/051210/11/ … 4d1191.jpg Apr 15 06 11:38 pm Link MarkMarek wrote: Mark, thanks for your encouragement! It all helps. I appreciate your compliments. Apr 15 06 11:59 pm Link yeah, same for me, great portfolio but i choose this one as for me the picture hasn t the same impact that the others ones..; https://img4.modelmayhem.com/060413/11/ … 879599.jpg Apr 16 06 09:40 am Link no more players???? come on, let s play... Apr 22 06 11:48 pm Link Long time listener, first time caller. Wouldnt mind playing, would help to get some critiques. I realize I'm still mostly a beginner but can use all the help I can get. Apr 23 06 12:08 am Link DeanP wrote: https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic_id=43fa95ef9a799 Apr 23 06 12:18 am Link Thank you I appreciate it, still trying to get all 100 aspects of an image together, keep getting stuck around #15 Dean Apr 23 06 12:23 am Link el_chulo wrote: You wanna play El chulo? Apr 23 06 12:26 am Link I wanna play https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic_id=438c8025bae06 I am just not feeling this pic and your body language in it. Apr 23 06 12:34 am Link One12 Images wrote: Yea, I hear you on that one. I was going to take it down... Apr 23 06 12:40 am Link Alright i'm truly enjoying looking through this thread and I find it interesting to see what people have to say, and how opinions contrast....now who would be so kind as to pick on my port and critique? Honesty is most appreciated! Thanks, Nishga Apr 23 06 12:42 am Link Apr 23 06 12:43 am Link Hey JustineDanielle, I really like your variation in your port but of all the photos, i feel that your third one (sorry i'm not that computerly smart to copy it on here) is not as strong as your other ones. You have a very nice face and a confident and appealing look but with all that hair in your face it does not come across. But thats just one girls opinion, the girl who happened to read the thread after you. Best of luck and keep it going, Nishga xoxo Apr 23 06 12:47 am Link Mandie wrote: for you, https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pic_id=4397e70a9a0e5 Apr 23 06 12:47 am Link |
