Forums > General Industry > Photographers getting all the credit

Model

Lapis

Posts: 8424

Chicago, Illinois, US

For collaborative projects where the model, MUA or wardrobe stylist came up with the idea. C'mon folks, here on the higher realm where I operate, collaboration is the greatest thing to happen, and everyone contributes. More people need to realize that. Great models do more than pose. They give ideas, etc. Great MUA's and wardrobe stylists are the same way. There is more than one time I have had to direct a shoot and change the lighting (especially for paid shoots) because I knew more about the photography than the photographer.....does that mean I list myself as artistic director as well as model? The arrogance of some (mostly mediocre, sorry) photographers is a huge turn off. I WILL NOT work with anyone who considers me a bowl of fruit....unless it is Ocean Clark.

Aug 15 06 04:49 pm Link

Photographer

Tog

Posts: 55204

Birmingham, Alabama, US

I will gladly pay half to any model who gets some poor sucker to buy my work..  wink

Of course most of the releases models want to sign say no sales, promotion only..  After all, everyone knows I'm a blatant pornographer.

Aug 15 06 04:52 pm Link

Photographer

Webspinner Studios

Posts: 6964

Ann Arbor, Michigan, US

WG Rowland wrote:
After all, everyone knows I'm a blatant pornographer.

yeah, you gotta stop taking pictures of naked poodles....and what about Mosley? Didn't he contribute to your shoots for a while? What happened to him?

Aug 15 06 04:54 pm Link

Photographer

Malameel

Posts: 1087

Dallas, Texas, US

Funny, how people think the model did all the work, I have to direct them, show them how to pose, how to express, and basicaly do there job.  And after all this work, people think all I did was push the button.

It goes both ways, there are idiots on both sides of the fence.

The best thing is to be concerned with what you are doing and move on.  You do not like a photographer or model or MUA or whatever, then get what you can nd move on...
M

Aug 15 06 04:55 pm Link

Photographer

Tog

Posts: 55204

Birmingham, Alabama, US

Uh.. Someone asked to buy a print of him.. So I had to kill him to up my cut..

But I'd never do that to anyone else!

Aug 15 06 04:55 pm Link

Photographer

UnoMundo

Posts: 47532

Olympia, Washington, US

Lapis wrote:
For collaborative projects where the model, MUA or wardrobe stylist came up with the idea. C'mon folks, here on the higher realm where I operate, collaboration is the greatest thing to happen, and everyone contributes. More people need to realize that. Great models do more than pose. They give ideas, etc. Great MUA's and wardrobe stylists are the same way. There is more than one time I have had to direct a shoot and change the lighting (especially for paid shoots) because I knew more about the photography than the photographer.....does that mean I list myself as artistic director as well as model? The arrogance of some (mostly mediocre, sorry) photographers is a huge turn off. I WILL NOT work with anyone who considers me a bowl of fruit....unless it is Ocean Clark.

Doctors recommend eating fruit every day.   
I see thousands of photos that never mention the model's name.

We keep our models secret. No one else must see them.

Aug 15 06 04:56 pm Link

Photographer

Tog

Posts: 55204

Birmingham, Alabama, US

MalameelPhotography wrote:
Funny, how people think the model did all the work, I have to direct them, show them how to pose, how to express, and basicaly do there job.  And after all this work, people think all I did was push the button.

It goes both ways, there are idiots on both sides of the fence.

The best thing is to be concerned with what you are doing and move on.  You do not like a photographer or model or MUA or whatever, then get what you can nd move on...
M

Oh wait.. Yeah.. It's all me..

Forget that half thing..

Use em and lose em..

Aug 15 06 04:57 pm Link

Photographer

Wolf 189

Posts: 4834

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Dear Lapis

Would you be my "bowl of fruit"?! smile



Just kidding of course...you can be anything you like as long as you pose.

Cheers

Wolf

Aug 15 06 04:58 pm Link

Model

Lapis

Posts: 8424

Chicago, Illinois, US

Wolf189 wrote:
Dear Lapis

Would you be my "bowl of fruit"?! smile

Here's the result of my 24 y.o. fantasy to be painted like a bowl of fruit carried on a platter into a room (and I wonder why I model....)

https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pid=1159311

Aug 15 06 05:09 pm Link

Photographer

Wolf 189

Posts: 4834

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Lapis wrote:

Here's the result of my 24 y.o. fantasy to be painted like a bowl of fruit carried on a platter into a room (and I wonder why I model....)

https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pid=1159311

This is so fun! A lot of work....I wonder if people will try to grab the bowl instead of the fruits! I am being silly.

How did you like the result? And did the photographer appreciate your idea?

Aug 15 06 05:26 pm Link

Photographer

Christopher Hartman

Posts: 54196

Buena Park, California, US

I like to eat fruit.

Aug 15 06 05:31 pm Link

Photographer

Tog

Posts: 55204

Birmingham, Alabama, US

DigitalCMH wrote:
I like to eat fruit.

Another conservative out of the closet.. smile

Aug 15 06 05:34 pm Link

Photographer

Archived

Posts: 13509

Phoenix, Arizona, US

Don't test with mediocre photographers, and you won't have that problem. You shouldn't be working with photographers that know less about lighting than you do, unless you're getting paid, and unless you're getting paid to art direct, don't art direct. Test up.

Lapis wrote:
There is more than one time I have had to direct a shoot and change the lighting (especially for paid shoots) because I knew more about the photography than the photographer.....does that mean I list myself as artistic director as well as model? The arrogance of some (mostly mediocre, sorry) photographers is a huge turn off.

Aug 15 06 05:39 pm Link

Photographer

Jwill266

Posts: 449

Louisville, Kentucky, US

Some food or fruit, what ever you want to call it, for thought

https://img2.modelmayhem.com/050908/16/ … 471d25.jpg

Aug 15 06 05:41 pm Link

Model

Lapis

Posts: 8424

Chicago, Illinois, US

Dave Wright Photo wrote:

Don't test with mediocre photographers, and you won't have that problem. You shouldn't be working with photographers that know less about lighting than you do, unless you're getting paid, and unless you're getting paid to art direct, don't art direct. Test up.

Yep. I don't work with photographers who know less about lighting than I do unless they are paying me. I think you can tell (hopefully) from my port I personally have no problem with the collaboration with artists aspect. I don't work with new photographers for free....I work testing only if they intrigue me and I want to frame some of their photographs and put them on my wall....so I usually work only with gallery/art/fashion photographers on a testing level.

I am just saying that it is usually mediocre photographers working with mediocre or inexperienced models who are the ones complaining they do all the work, and don't appreciate the collaborative nature of true art.

Aug 15 06 05:46 pm Link

Photographer

Photocraft

Posts: 631

Ann Arbor, Michigan, US

Credit? Do I get a card to go with it, I need some new gear.

Aug 15 06 06:13 pm Link

Model

Iona Lynn

Posts: 11176

Oakland, California, US

Good point Lapis but this seems to be the way of the photography world.

I think this is part of the reason I started shooting more and more is because I have ideas and I want the credit and fame and money errm I want something???
for my ideas and hard work not the photographer who says it is a great idea and uses it to promote themselves and sell my brain as well as my body.


That is why I am working more and more with long term projects where I trust I am not only a part of the begining of the project I will also be a part of the end result and gain credit as well as a paycheck.

It does take a while to get there though new models can't just walk up to a photographer and say

"Hey I get credit in your work as well right?"

I think you have to prove yor self in this crazy art world a bit.

Aug 15 06 06:14 pm Link

Photographer

Tog

Posts: 55204

Birmingham, Alabama, US

I want a cookie..

..or a collaborator with marketing skills.

Aug 15 06 06:17 pm Link

Photographer

Archived

Posts: 13509

Phoenix, Arizona, US

You know, it's always the lead singer that gets all the credit.

Your first post seems to be a rant about personal experience, and then with the post I'm quoting here, you change it to a rant about the world in general. Why are you concerned with people who are mediocre and complaining? I try ignore those types of people as much as possible.

Lapis wrote:
I am just saying that it is usually mediocre photographers working with mediocre or inexperienced models who are the ones complaining they do all the work, and don't appreciate the collaborative nature of true art.

Aug 15 06 06:18 pm Link

Model

Phoenix E

Posts: 596

i completely sympathize, ma chere. fortunately, i think anyone who takes even a few seconds to converse with you will realize that you are more than just a pretty face.
but it is a sad fact that art models are often underappreciated. while most people consider photographers artists few give models that same compliment.
i think that turning yourself into a piece of art is the greatest accomplishment.

Aug 15 06 06:18 pm Link

Photographer

byReno

Posts: 1034

Arlington Heights, Illinois, US

Lapis wrote:
Here's the result of my 24 y.o. fantasy to be painted like a bowl of fruit carried on a platter into a room (and I wonder why I model....)

https://modelmayhem.com/pic.php?pid=1159311

Did you notice the model did not get credited?  I'd like to think of you more like a bowl of tangy HOT peppers. 

I do notice this a bit and the reverse, plenty of comments on model’s page but nothing on the photographer’s page.  If you are becoming the art director, negotiate a work for hire sort of arrangement or collaboration credit for that specific image.

I’d rest assured, a model capable of become one’s muse, becomes self evident to the viewer.  Their contributions don’t go unnoticed.

Aug 15 06 06:25 pm Link

Photographer

Kentsoul

Posts: 9739

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, US

MalameelPhotography wrote:
Funny, how people think the model did all the work, I have to direct them, show them how to pose, how to express, and basicaly do there job.  And after all this work, people think all I did was push the button.

You need to start choosing better models then.  I never have this problem.

Aug 15 06 06:29 pm Link

Photographer

Photocraft

Posts: 631

Ann Arbor, Michigan, US

I wonder why there isn't a governing body parallel to Hollywood guilds rules about contribution vs. credits on films?

  Of course, you do have the option of buying/negotiating any rights/ownership/credit for a project. Sure the default is for the photographer to come up with the vision, but there's nothing keeping you from charting your own course.

Aug 15 06 06:41 pm Link

Photographer

Robert Bussey

Posts: 480

Andover, New Hampshire, US

Fairly noisy thread here but I'll toss in my dime: Working with staff, models, stylists, etc who do not contribute to the effort attenuate its outcome. As the lensman it feels like swimming against the tide.

When I have to spend 80% of my time trying to get an expression or pose, well heck, here's the check kiddo, call back when you know what your doing and out they go.

I am proud to say that with some of my fav stuff all I did was "push the button" because the model knew what was expected, the assistant knew where to put the light, the stylist knew what to do - without any conversation, no yelling, just everyone working in harmony, working as a team. Synergy people, its all about synergy.

IMHO, in the hot, stuffy, confining space of a small studio there has to be a connection felt between all especially when trying to shoot art. and... always, but always give credit where credit is due! When the team works as it should, everyone gets on the credit line. When it doesn't, there is no credit line.

JM2C
b-

Aug 15 06 06:46 pm Link

Photographer

Kentsoul

Posts: 9739

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, US

Iona Lynn wrote:
Good point Lapis but this seems to be the way of the photography world.

Then you're working with the wrong photographers.

Aug 15 06 06:50 pm Link

Photographer

J Schumacher

Posts: 1220

Gustine, California, US

Models always get credit from me, and as far as I know, I always get credit from them. It's a creative thing, I can't do it alone, unless I wanted to do landscapes and sunsets or something. I like people in a shot, though, so I need assistance. (guess I could shoot myself, but then no one would look at the photos....)

Aug 15 06 06:54 pm Link

Photographer

Lens N Light

Posts: 16341

Bradford, Vermont, US

If you have a good idea for a shoot, hire a photographer to shoot it and you own the images. You can bill yorself as model and art director.

Aug 15 06 06:55 pm Link

Photographer

Ivan Aps

Posts: 4996

Miami, Florida, US

It is a tough answer.  Lets say you have an idea, but it will require some serious post production creative work to make it a reality....if someone else spends 12 hours in post production, does the person who just thought of the idea but didn't make it reality still deserve credit?

Look at the real world.  A really great ad campaign....you might now who shot it.  You might know who the model is.....but how often do you get to see who it was that created the idea behind the set and layout and the overall idea to start with?  Basically, never.

If you want the credit, do the who thing.  Create it, shoot it and if you can, model in it.  That way you know what a photographer goes through with the final product.  If then the shot sucks, everyone always blames the photographer even if technically the image is good.  That is why people credit us.  They compliment us if a image is good and laugh at us when it is bad.

Aug 15 06 07:02 pm Link

Photographer

Kentsoul

Posts: 9739

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, US

Lens N Light wrote:
If you have a good idea for a shoot, hire a photographer to shoot it and you own the images. You can bill yorself as model and art director.

This thread is giving me new insight into why i have no trouble finding models...

Aug 15 06 07:03 pm Link

Photographer

Photocraft

Posts: 631

Ann Arbor, Michigan, US

BobPhotos wrote:
Fairly noisy thread here but I'll toss in my dime: Working with staff, models, stylists, etc who do not contribute to the effort attenuate its outcome. As the lensman it feels like swimming against the tide.

When I have to spend 80% of my time trying to get an expression or pose, well heck, here's the check kiddo, call back when you know what your doing and out they go.

I am proud to say that with some of my fav stuff all I did was "push the button" because the model knew what was expected, the assistant knew where to put the light, the stylist knew what to do - without any conversation, no yelling, just everyone working in harmony, working as a team. Synergy people, its all about synergy.

IMHO, in the hot, stuffy, confining space of a small studio there has to be a connection felt between all especially when trying to shoot art. and... always, but always give credit where credit is due! When the team works as it should, everyone gets on the credit line. When it doesn't, there is no credit line.

JM2C
b-

So the two model names as titles in your port count as the credit line, or no? 8)

Aug 15 06 07:03 pm Link

Photographer

Robert Bussey

Posts: 480

Andover, New Hampshire, US

caption  credit line

Aug 15 06 07:09 pm Link

Photographer

Jean-Philippe

Posts: 397

Austin, Texas, US

Lapis wrote:
For collaborative projects where the model, MUA or wardrobe stylist came up with the idea. C'mon folks, here on the higher realm where I operate, collaboration is the greatest thing to happen, and everyone contributes. More people need to realize that. Great models do more than pose. They give ideas, etc. Great MUA's and wardrobe stylists are the same way. There is more than one time I have had to direct a shoot and change the lighting (especially for paid shoots) because I knew more about the photography than the photographer.....does that mean I list myself as artistic director as well as model? The arrogance of some (mostly mediocre, sorry) photographers is a huge turn off. I WILL NOT work with anyone who considers me a bowl of fruit....unless it is Ocean Clark.

If you come to me with an idea... you have become a client:
You pay and I don't need credit ;-)
You'll go home happy with the picture that you wanted to create and I'll do it as much as I can to make it looks as you imagined it.
Now, If you know what to do with the picture and you are the one putting it on the market, you don't need the photographer to give you credit for anything. You buy the picture rights, you get it to print and can add as many credits as you want aside the picture.

If you collaborate with a photographer, just make sure that you know the person before you shoot. Just don't work with people that are no playing by the same rules you do play. Nah?

Aug 15 06 07:17 pm Link

Photographer

Jean-Philippe

Posts: 397

Austin, Texas, US

Lens N Light wrote:
If you have a good idea for a shoot, hire a photographer to shoot it and you own the images. You can bill yorself as model and art director.

Oops... I took too long to reply and you did say the same thing in 2 lines tongue

Aug 15 06 07:20 pm Link

Photographer

Leonard Gee Photography

Posts: 18096

Sacramento, California, US

We can add a movie metadata tag to photos. It'll be a crawling credit list - just like the movies.

You know, the clapper loader, focus puller, caterer, drivers, electric company, camera company, flash card company, unions, bank and finance companies, insurance, accountant, electrician, plummer, carpenter, set painter, assistant set painter, building owner, makeup artist, toilet paper brand, shoe brands, clothes manufacture, escort service. Why leave anyone out?

Aug 15 06 07:25 pm Link

Photographer

Beatbox Jeebus v2

Posts: 10046

Palatine, Illinois, US

Credit goes to where credit is do. Some of my favorite shots have been because of collaborating with other artists: models, muas, bodypainters, stylist, etc. It all a team effort.

Aug 15 06 07:27 pm Link