This thread was locked on 2007-01-06 12:16:31
Forums > General Industry > Warning!!!!!!

Model

Darkdesire

Posts: 588

Tucson, Arizona, US

Runed Sky Photographics wrote:

but you don't seem to want to do anything except get attention?

i have done something i contacted the mods...about her.

Jan 06 07 04:34 am Link

Model

SUSI_mg8

Posts: 218

NORTH HOLLYWOOD, California, US

Runed Sky Photographics wrote:
so really, you're not concerned with your friend and the photographer's situation, it's just a slow night and you're looking for company?

i think the purpose of this thread was just to ALErt other photogs in the area which i think should be appreciated. I think all the replies got out of context making it seem as if her intentions were others..

just my 2 cents..

Jan 06 07 04:42 am Link

Model

Iris

Posts: 950

Dallas, Texas, US

Darkdesire wrote:

thats the thing she has her ex bf call me...i try to find out what happened and they won't tell me shit...its sad knowing somebody for so long and then she pulls this shit...

There is a huge difference between.

Girl accuses someone of something...
Boyfriend says that girl says something...

You allow your friend of 10 years' b/f to tell you a story,  which is out of character for her, and you believe it?  And then tell everyone else...

That's called gossip...

If she didn't tell you, it's wrong to believe & spread a second hand story.

Jan 06 07 04:45 am Link

Model

MsHeidi

Posts: 2081

Jessheim, Akershus, Norway

Darkdesire wrote:

in this case it was a good thing...

Yeah! My point exactly!

Jan 06 07 04:52 am Link

Photographer

Sharen Style

Posts: 178

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

SUSI_mg8 wrote:
i think the purpose of this thread was just to ALErt other photogs in the area which i think should be appreciated. I think all the replies got out of context making it seem as if her intentions were others..

I can understand her being defensive to an extent if she truely were a victim witness, which is why I thought she needed to clear her head and gather her thoughts before she started to make things up to fill in the details or made false assumptions, which is a very natural human response to such confusing situations, and let the right people who should know (the police at this point) know about it.

The part I'm not so sure about is if this is a real situation and the police have been called, why does she seem reluctant to do more than just spread this story here and alert the mods here about the model, and being seemingly more concerned about her personal credibility than the credibility of her tale?

I'm sorry, the situation is very plausible and there are certain points to both "he raped her" and "he didn't rape her", but I'm starting to lean towards "model turf war".....

Jan 06 07 04:53 am Link

Model

AprilinCA

Posts: 235

Murrieta, California, US

Runed Sky Photographics wrote:

I can understand her being defensive to an extent if she truely were a victim witness, which is why I thought she needed to clear her head and gather her thoughts before she started to make things up to fill in the details or made false assumptions, which is a very natural human response to such confusing situations, and let the right people who should know (the police at this point) know about it.

The part I'm not so sure about is if this is a real situation and the police have been called, why does she seem reluctant to do more than just spread this story here and alert the mods here about the model, and being seemingly more concerned about her personal credibility than the credibility of her tale?

I'm sorry, the situation is very plausible and there are certain points to both "he raped her" and "he didn't rape her", but I'm starting to lean towards "model turf war".....

It seems that you missed the complete point. She didnt say that the photographer raped this particular person. But that the person is making the CLAIM that she was raped by this photographer.

She is warning that this woman who happened to be a friend of hers and was introduced to this photographer BY the OP is CLAIMING something happened that didn't happen.

The OP can't be held accountable for what the other party does or does not do about her claim, but the OP took what might be appropriate action by reporting this individual to the mods here.

And in case you didn't know it's very important that the OP mentions this since all it takes is the ACCUSATION that a man raped/hit a women to turn his entire life upside down. What the OP may be doing in this case is saving a mans reputation before the supposed victim comes on here making accusations and the people here immediatly jump to her defense and bashing the photographer without knowing anything about the situation. It's happened MANY times before.

Jan 06 07 05:08 am Link

Photographer

UIPHOTOS

Posts: 3591

Dayton, Ohio, US

Darkdesire wrote:
in this case it was a good thing...

MsHeidi wrote:
Yeah! My point exactly!

HOW was this a good thing..??  The photog got ACCUSED anyway..

Whether it really happened or not is irrelevant at this point since people will assume SOMETHING must have happened for her to say it..

So that extra body and extra set of eyes did NO ONE any good.. if anything it proves how little it actually does..

Now she can scream she HAD an escort and got raped.. while he can say there was an escort there and he STILL got accused.. Where is the plus side of this..??

Jan 06 07 05:13 am Link

Photographer

Sharen Style

Posts: 178

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

You misunderstand me... I agree with you totally on this taking impact on the reputations of all parties involved and how significant that is. Whether the model's claim is true or not is besides the point, which I completely agree.

The question I'm raising is: why is the OP, as what appears to be a key witness, knowing this significance, only appear to be willing to state her claims to this online forum and not to the authorities who, as she claims, have already been called by the model who is telling them that this photographer raped her?

Jan 06 07 05:15 am Link

Model

AprilinCA

Posts: 235

Murrieta, California, US

Runed Sky Photographics wrote:
You misunderstand me... I agree with you totally on this taking impact on the reputations of all parties involved and how significant that is. Whether the model's claim is true or not is besides the point, which I completely agree.

The question I'm raising is: why is the OP, as what appears to be a key witness, knowing this significance, only appear to be willing to state her claims to this online forum and not to the authorities who, as she claims, have already been called by the model who is telling them that this photographer raped her?

When the authorities contact her she will then have opportunity to tell them if they haven't already. But the authorities aren't on this board, and here is where the professional reputations of the individuals involved could/would be damaged as well.

The point I think is that she is trying to head off the ASSumptions that people make as was mentioned previously that because the model in question made the accusation something MUST have happened. Something that people are quick to judge, when in truth there are a lot of people accused of rapes that NEVER happened, but are already convicted in the public eye because of police involvement.

Jan 06 07 05:20 am Link

Model

AprilinCA

Posts: 235

Murrieta, California, US

UIPHOTOS wrote:
Now she can scream she HAD an escort and got raped.. while he can say there was an escort there and he STILL got accused.. Where is the plus side of this..??

The PLUS side is that if it has to go to court there are an extra set of eyes to testify on behalf of the injured party, because in reality THAT is where it REALLY counts. In court.

Jan 06 07 05:22 am Link

Photographer

Patrick Walberg

Posts: 45475

San Juan Bautista, California, US

As far as "outing" a model OR a photographer, it's not wise because it contributes more potential drama (gossip) to the story, AND it's against the rules here. This is not some sort of "model/photographer court" nor is it possible for any of us to know the truth.  We were not there. 

I started a thread regarding how escorts can be utilized, and this is an example of how the models escort has provided a strong alibi for the photographer in an unusual twist of fate! Wow!  Now I understand why I am the one who actually feels more comfortable when there is an escort! 

One of my own family members who used to be very supportive of me had started a nasty rumor attack on me after I caught her in a lie on something that is devastating her life.  She has been in denial; of her problem, so she struck back at me the most personal way possible.   As far as I can tell, it back fired on her.  What damage that has been done is not as bad as it has been to her own reputation. 

I would not do anything to destroy my career.  What that model attempted to do in reporting a false rape could potential destroy that photographers career.  In her having you accompany her at the shoot, you became a protector to the photographer.  It's highly unusual that something like this happens, but you are to be commended for making a stand for truth.  Integrity is more than just words. 
Thank you.

Jan 06 07 05:28 am Link

Photographer

Sharen Style

Posts: 178

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

AprilinCA wrote:
When the authorities contact her she will then have opportunity to tell them if they haven't already.

Considering that the person filing the report is the model claiming to be raped, chances are slim that the accusing model would tell the police that the OP was there and saw everything unless the OP was going to agree to her story.... by the time they get to the OP it might even be too late for the photographer. As much as the states take an official "innocent until proven guilty" stance, the law enforcement and most people take the "guilty until proven innocent" route, even if he was only arreseted but not convicted he would still be harmed!

AprilinCA wrote:
But the authorities aren't on this board, and here is where the professional reputations of the individuals involved could/would be damaged as well.

My flags went up when all she seemed intrested in doing was ruining the model on the board, and not protecting the photographer IRL

AprilinCA wrote:
The point I think is that she is trying to head off the ASSumptions that people make as was mentioned previously that because the model in question made the accusation something MUST have happened. Something that people are quick to judge, when in truth there are a lot of people accused of rapes that NEVER happened, but are already convicted in the public eye because of police involvement.

I remember someone mentioned the possibility that both the OP and the model's story might be true if perhaps the model had another encounter with the photographer without the OP's knowledge or being there and the OP, possibly misunderstanding, heading off on a more detailed description of what happened the night of the shoot she escorted. But I don't think the point that the photographer MUST have done it or MUST NOT have done it has been raised by anyone but the OP. I could have missed something?

Jan 06 07 05:32 am Link

Photographer

Patrick Walberg

Posts: 45475

San Juan Bautista, California, US

AprilinCA wrote:

The PLUS side is that if it has to go to court there are an extra set of eyes to testify on behalf of the injured party, because in reality THAT is where it REALLY counts. In court.

If it gets that far.  I've seen accusations made by someone in my own family backfire and make her look like the liar she is.  In my case, there were no names or witnesses to any wrong doing.  I refused to go to places or get into circumstances that she tried to set my up for.  Photographers having their own escorts is not a bad idea!

Jan 06 07 05:35 am Link

Photographer

Patrick Walberg

Posts: 45475

San Juan Bautista, California, US

AprilinCA wrote:

When the authorities contact her she will then have opportunity to tell them if they haven't already. But the authorities aren't on this board, and here is where the professional reputations of the individuals involved could/would be damaged as well.

The point I think is that she is trying to head off the ASSumptions that people make as was mentioned previously that because the model in question made the accusation something MUST have happened. Something that people are quick to judge, when in truth there are a lot of people accused of rapes that NEVER happened, but are already convicted in the public eye because of police involvement.

"If" the authorities were actually contacted!

Jan 06 07 05:37 am Link

Photographer

glenn my name today

Posts: 1025

Lancaster, California, US

i dont know what the issue is except for bad music.

re-read what she wrote.

she said her friend told her she was rapped by the photographer.

isnt that what happens when you play too much rap music?
sexual assault is rape or raped. bad urban music assault is rapped.

which one is it?

Jan 06 07 07:40 am Link

Photographer

00siris

Posts: 19182

New York, New York, US

Darkdesire wrote:
[...]I have been rapped at a shoot before as well...and [...]

Jan 06 07 09:21 am Link

Model

Yahshikar cajuncameleon

Posts: 45

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

Darkdesire wrote:

good idea i'm gonna do that and not continue this topic...have a mod shut it down..

i think it would be a bunch of shit...if you were there, followed her everywhere, or never left her alone with the photog, but why would she accuse him of rape if he never touched her, maybe she wants to say, foundled, or rubbed, ask....RAPE is one of those crimes tht's hard to fake, or do with out entering unwanted territory.

Jan 06 07 09:33 am Link

Model

Yahshikar cajuncameleon

Posts: 45

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

Kalene wrote:

There is a huge difference between.

Girl accuses someone of something...
Boyfriend says that girl says something...

You allow your friend of 10 years' b/f to tell you a story,  which is out of character for her, and you believe it?  And then tell everyone else...

That's called gossip...

If she didn't tell you, it's wrong to believe & spread a second hand story.

i agree with tht!!!

Jan 06 07 09:37 am Link

Model

Yahshikar cajuncameleon

Posts: 45

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

Runed Sky Photographics wrote:
I can understand her being defensive to an extent if she truely were a victim witness, which is why I thought she needed to clear her head and gather her thoughts before she started to make things up to fill in the details or made false assumptions, which is a very natural human response to such confusing situations, and let the right people who should know (the police at this point) know about it.

The part I'm not so sure about is if this is a real situation and the police have been called, why does she seem reluctant to do more than just spread this story here and alert the mods here about the model, and being seemingly more concerned about her personal credibility than the credibility of her tale?

I'm sorry, the situation is very plausible and there are certain points to both "he raped her" and "he didn't rape her", but I'm starting to lean towards "model turf war".....

well...i agree with you, and i see what she was trying to do as well.  but my thing is this is a friend of 10YEARS....!! how long has she been knowing the photog, people are different infront of others all the time, (social behaviors), so maybe, but if it did happen, or not, i think she sould have talked with her friend, and to be honest i would've  never posted this.  I would have left it as a warning thread and thts tht!! or used it as  a+ for models who do come with an escort, and how this would benefit both model and photog as intended.

Jan 06 07 09:42 am Link

Photographer

Mac Wolff

Posts: 3665

Litchfield Park, Arizona, US

Hey Steph, I see your point and agree, that has long been a worry of mine, even though I would never do something like that the thought of having that happen, being accused is so  disheartening, I take my female partner as much as I can (you hvae met her)  but that is not always the norn as we take our share of shoots and split them.
Keep up the good work girl !!


Mac

Jan 06 07 09:54 am Link

Model

Yahshikar cajuncameleon

Posts: 45

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

Patrick Walberg wrote:
If it gets that far.  I've seen accusations made by someone in my own family backfire and make her look like the liar she is.  In my case, there were no names or witnesses to any wrong doing.  I refused to go to places or get into circumstances that she tried to set my up for.  Photographers having their own escorts is not a bad idea!

i just picked this response, but....this is why doctors male or female have a nurse in there when doing a pap, or anythign dealing with a women and her genital area.  Its to bare witness to the actions taking place.  So i would think tht as a photog, accepting the escort may not be so bad.  And it is a good thing, though ironic,tht a friend of ten  years, claiming tht nothign happened will stand in court.  But what they have to do is investigate, there's semen tht has to be tested for,and all three will share their sides of the stroy. To be honest, if he were named i still wouldn't judge him, i'd be confused to why  she'd make a story liek tht up when the severity of rape is so intense, "what so she can get the pics for free?"(motive?). The question whether he did it or not will never be known to us, And souldn't since the names of the photog and model or kept in secrecy.  Which mean every1 is safe.  So reputations wont be damaged.  I saw someone trying to warn the witness, of her saying, and watch for what she's doing.  Even though you're not posting the names of the photog/model here, if they email you you will, and you may expose her to an angry photog who may leak it, which isn't fair to her(model), if it is true tht he did, cause now her reputation is damaged, and vise versa. So i would play it safe."

Jan 06 07 09:59 am Link

Model

UnavailableNonExistant

Posts: 294

Columbus, Ohio, US

I'm getting the distinct impression that the BF isn't happy about her going on the shoot, so she made up the story in order to act as if she was a victim in order to get him off her ass. This is why it came 2 days later and she only talked to the BF.

My advice, slap your friend for being an idiot and tell the photographer you have his back, and that he should sue her for defemation of character, filing false charges and that'll learn her lying ass.

Though one question I have for you, were you in their presence the whole time? was there ever a time that they had a good 15 minutes of alone time and she came out looking disheveled and him with a shit eating grin on his face?

Jan 06 07 10:21 am Link

Photographer

Jose Luis

Posts: 2890

Dallas, Texas, US

This kinda speaks to the maturity level of models who require escorts.  I get it in a paid gwc shoot where a model is acting as a glorified stripper.  I dont get it in a real portfolio building collaboration situation.

Jan 06 07 10:26 am Link

Photographer

richard boswell

Posts: 1790

New York, New York, US

female partner in a business sense, or in a personal sense. 
either is much better than no one, how ever a witness not in partnership
with you would probably be a better witness. 
like an independent contractor makeup artist for example.
she presumably has no conflict of interest influencing her testimony.

rich


wolff wrote:
Hey Steph, I see your point and agree, that has long been a worry of mine, even though I would never do something like that the thought of having that happen, being accused is so  disheartening, I take my female partner as much as I can (you hvae met her)  but that is not always the norn as we take our share of shoots and split them.
Keep up the good work girl !!


Mac

Jan 06 07 11:27 am Link

Photographer

Meech Creative LLC

Posts: 97

Frederick, Maryland, US

*raped

Jan 06 07 11:31 am Link

Photographer

richard boswell

Posts: 1790

New York, New York, US

if the person telling the truth leaks the name of the one not telling the truth. 
that would not be slander or liable, and would imo be in the bests interests of this community, and society in general.
(unless it is a confused truth)
which does not seem to be the case from the information provided.


Yahshikar cajuncameleon wrote:

i just picked this response, but....this is why doctors male or female have a nurse in there when doing a pap, or anythign dealing with a women and her genital area.  Its to bare witness to the actions taking place.  So i would think tht as a photog, accepting the escort may not be so bad.  And it is a good thing, though ironic,tht a friend of ten  years, claiming tht nothign happened will stand in court.  But what they have to do is investigate, there's semen tht has to be tested for,and all three will share their sides of the stroy. To be honest, if he were named i still wouldn't judge him, i'd be confused to why  she'd make a story liek tht up when the severity of rape is so intense, "what so she can get the pics for free?"(motive?). The question whether he did it or not will never be known to us, And souldn't since the names of the photog and model or kept in secrecy.  Which mean every1 is safe.  So reputations wont be damaged.  I saw someone trying to warn the witness, of her saying, and watch for what she's doing.  Even though you're not posting the names of the photog/model here, if they email you you will, and you may expose her to an angry photog who may leak it, which isn't fair to her(model), if it is true tht he did, cause now her reputation is damaged, and vise versa. So i would play it safe."

Jan 06 07 11:34 am Link

Photographer

Sophistocles

Posts: 21320

Seattle, Washington, US

After reading this whole thread (and I want those three minutes of my life back, please), I'm prepared to go out on a limb...

I don't believe a word of it.

Jan 06 07 11:35 am Link

Photographer

Nihilus

Posts: 10888

Nashville, Tennessee, US

Christopher Ambler wrote:
I don't believe a word of it.

Which part? *scratching head*

Jan 06 07 11:44 am Link

Photographer

SKPhoto

Posts: 25784

Newark, California, US

Christopher Ambler wrote:
After reading this whole thread (and I want those three minutes of my life back, please), I'm prepared to go out on a limb...

I don't believe a word of it.

Starting to sound an awful lot like a "look-rape", or an "I know he wanted to too-rape".


Shameful photographers should just make sure their tinfoil hats are securely attached before shooting.

Jan 06 07 11:44 am Link

Photographer

Skydancer Photos

Posts: 22196

Santa Cruz, California, US

Darkdesire wrote:
I hate doing this or anything...but of the 4th of janurary I escorted a friend of mine to a shoot. I won't say her name or the photographers if you want to know who email me..I arrived early to the shoot to help set things up for her, and be there before she arrived...never left her side...shamefully this woman is claiming the photographer rapped her and thats just not possible. I have traveled shot alone with this person more times then I can count, and hang out with him once twice a week..my sister shoots with him too and speaks highly of him. I would never ever work with a slimeball. I have been rapped at a shoot before as well...and take this seriously!!!! I truely hate people trying to ruin others, and I will never ever recommend this lady!! You think you know somebody after 10 freaking yrs...please becareful people..this man is innocent!!!

Hmmmm. I would suggest personal caution and discretion. If I read this thread right, you say you received a call from a model's BF saying that she was raped at the session you were her escort at... and that you can attest to the fact that you were at her side the whole time and nothing happened. You don't say that she, or her BF, are posting here on MM or anywhere else in public accusing him of raping her. Yet you come on this public website and start talking about this "situation" AND tell people to message you if we want to know the names of the people involved. WTF. Frankly, this reeks of gossip and drama mongering. Why are you here talking about this? Have you tried to call this model? Do you know what the actual details of the accusations are, and whether or not the BF or model have gone public with the accusations? Have you contacted the photog? Have you contacted the police... especially since you were informed of an allegation that you would be a witness to?

Jan 06 07 11:49 am Link

Photographer

richard boswell

Posts: 1790

New York, New York, US

this is a really confusing thread,
it seems to me you should be talking to the police or the d.a.
or some sort of lawyer for one or the other of them.

you aren't in north carolina are you by any chance?

also unless this is a minor ...
a charge or even official accusation and all the details surrounding that charge/accusation
is a matter of public record or soon will be.  with the possible exception of her name.
unless i am mistaken ??

i'm shocked this isn't news worthy on at least a regional level. 
being raped is a big deal, being raped while on a photo shoot is news!

did something other than photography (but not a rape) happen?
and she had to make up a story for the BF
when he figured out what had happened? 

it's just hard to believe what you say is happening, can be happening.

with the slight details you have posted.  it seems very unlikely.

all this being said, ideally (just like with paperwork) both parties in a photo shoot
should have something/someone working in favor of their interests.

if you are on the up and up, a video surveillance system in your studio can be a good thing,
stories like this almost seem to make it an necessity.
if only to keep you baser desires in check. 
cell phone photos have saved people from jail time before,
and i suspect video surveillance systems have as well.
or at least worked in the interests of justice.

Jan 06 07 11:53 am Link

Model

LaViolette

Posts: 9865

Hollywood, Florida, US

A question to the op: Your friend's user name doesn't happen to contain something like the words "heart" & "desire" in it does it?

op I suggest you contact the mods to have this thread locked. It could get really ugly in here...

Jan 06 07 12:02 pm Link

Photographer

Attollo-Validus

Posts: 305

Austin, Texas, US

This is why I only shoot with either a MUA or my wife the studio manager present at any shoots.  I deal with false claims all the time as member of the LE community.  Everyone needs to protect themselves!!  We have actually considered placing a Security camera in the Studio (Not in private areas) to document and disprove any claims of harassment/sexual assault.  I hope to never worry about any claims against me and having to prove my innocence.  But the world is filled with those who can live in the fictional side of life. 

   My policy is that the model and the photographer will never be alone!  Period with out discussion.  There will always be another female present.

*************************************************************
I'm not getting into that Escort thing (Serious Brain Pain)  But I will ask this one little question?

If you bring a friend can I bring one too?   I would have been so pissed if my wife was at a shoot and the photog's buds came over to watch.  (Crap I went there, My brain pain is hurting)


Everyone needs to use some common sense, just don't put your self in a situation that creates a situation that one could twist reality. 

Models that have been accosted or assaulted please except my sincere sympathy.  Should this have happen to my wife I would. (Better to be left unsaid)

Jan 06 07 12:04 pm Link

Model

DELETE ACCOUNT

Posts: 5517

Eškašem, Badakhshan, Afghanistan

Y'know, the money that I'm no longer paying to OMP for yearly platinum plus memberships is already better spent.  I will seriously consider purchasing an MM membership when that opportunity again becomes available, unless bullshit threads like this and too many others continue to thrive and flourish.  Jesus, man.

Jan 06 07 12:06 pm Link

Photographer

Marcus J. Ranum

Posts: 3247

MORRISDALE, Pennsylvania, US

Darkdesire wrote:
i have done something i contacted the mods...about her.

So you're trying to get your "friend"s portfolio shut down?? Hmmmm...  This whole thing is pegging my "smells fishy"-meter all the way in the red zone.

Jan 06 07 12:10 pm Link

Photographer

Larry Brown Camera

Posts: 1081

Atlantic Beach, Florida, US

If you want legal advice...... "I stayed at a Holliday Inn last night!"  smile

Jan 06 07 12:13 pm Link