Forums > Digital Art and Retouching > Green Screen Question???

Photographer

MirrorImage Photography

Posts: 430

Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, US

Have never shot using green screen before, do i have to get from a special background dealer... or can i go to my local fabric store and get a bright green felt fabric to use??  tia

Apr 24 16 05:26 am Link

Photographer

TMA Photo and Training

Posts: 1009

Lancaster, Pennsylvania, US

Ive bought store fabric that was bright and very saturated and it worked out fine.   Just dont go into the reds or yellows or orange colors...the colors that skin is made up of.  The green and blue colors have been optimized for TV and software extraction with people as the foreground.  Make sure you have a way to stretch and hang your fabrics tightly to smooth out those pesky wrinkles that dont key well.  Some photographers prefer Chroma Key seamless background paper or painted foam core panels.    Dont get shiny or glossy fabrics...the shine sometimes doesnt cut out cleanly.

Apr 24 16 06:00 am Link

Photographer

WisconsinArt

Posts: 612

Nashotah, Wisconsin, US

Local camera shop sells kits which essentially contains a green cloth backdrop and software. You can probably find same at B&H.

What I wonder is how good it really works. I use a white backdrop and remove the background in Photoshop. That leaves a white edge around the object and I have to manually erase the edge which is tedious. I wonder if those kits leave an edge too.

Apr 24 16 06:35 am Link

Photographer

Shoreline Pictures

Posts: 100

Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada

There are paints made specifically for chroma key. A pure colour from your local paint store will work as well. A painted flat is much easier to use unless you have a way to stretch your fabric to a wrinkle free state.

Apr 24 16 07:35 am Link

Photographer

MirrorImage Photography

Posts: 430

Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, US

i want to use it with this software.....  http://www.owens-originals.com/green-sc … -p/gsw.htm

Apr 24 16 07:46 am Link

Photographer

Rays Fine Art

Posts: 7504

New York, New York, US

Shoreline Pictures wrote:
There are paints made specifically for chroma key. A pure colour from your local paint store will work as well. A painted flat is much easier to use unless you have a way to stretch your fabric to a wrinkle free state.

^This^ but whether you paint or use fabric, be sure that the material you use absorbs light as much as possible rather than reflecting it.  I made the mistake of using a medium luster latex wall paint and had to be extra careful to pose the model away from the green screen to avoid having  a greenish tint to the skin.

Apr 24 16 08:07 am Link

Photographer

Light and Lens Studio

Posts: 3450

Sisters, Oregon, US

MirrorImage Photography wrote:
Have never shot using green screen before, do i have to get from a special background dealer... or can i go to my local fabric store and get a bright green felt fabric to use??  tia

JoAnn Fabrics sells a green color called Kelly Green that is a near perfect match for some of the Chroma Green colors sold by background roll paper companies.

If you have a wall you can use, it is far superior to a cloth background for the reason of "wrinkles".  Wrinkles cause shadows (showing up as black after the green is removed) which may likely consume a significant amount of time getting rid of.  Lowes sells a tinting color called "Simply Green" also a very close match for chroma green.  I buy it in their Valspar line and use a flat finish.  Shiny spots (reflective highlights) are just as bad as wrinkles.

I have not used the GSW program you reference in another post.  Most of my green screen is done with video.  Final cut pro allows you to determine the range of green which the program will remove (A plug in called DV Matte Blast from DV Garage).  I don't know if GSW allows you to determine a range of green to be removed.  The GSW program does look good, and I've been tempted to buy it a few times, but I don't do enough green screen with stills to justify it.

Hope this helps.

Apr 24 16 08:20 am Link

Photographer

Phantasy Fhotos

Posts: 26

Chicago, Illinois, US

I use royal blue seamless paper which seems to work great for me as a chroma key color as well as a color in general.

Apr 24 16 08:34 am Link

Photographer

MirrorImage Photography

Posts: 430

Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, US

the software program has a built in feature, that you can just brush out the dark wrinkles... one easy step

Apr 24 16 08:54 am Link

Clothing Designer

GRMACK

Posts: 5436

Bakersfield, California, US

I watched a two-day live event with a composite photographer on Creative Live last month who uses a gray paper for her green screen. She explained a lot of valid reasons for it, most of which I forget.

She does show some before-and-afters here with the gray and the composites off it halfway down the page: http://petapixel.com/2015/09/15/renee-r … cle-crash/

She also shows it in her cool video on the same page too.  Gray?  But it works for her.

Apr 24 16 09:40 am Link

Retoucher

ST Retouch

Posts: 393

Amsterdam, Noord-Holland, Netherlands

For professional photography and real composite work , forget any green/screen backgrounds or any chroma key software.

Green/Blue Screen is for video composite work .
Even in video composite work chroma key  is just a basic step for extraction,  for top results later you have to work rotoscoping very often frame by frame.

For image composite work white/grey background  is industry standard .
Chroma key software with sliders and green/blue screen backgrounds is for quick amateurish results with tons of halo edges and problematic colors cast around, with some file maybe you can get some decent results with low res images but for serious results no.

If you want to  learn composite work - Photoshop only and white/grey backgrounds .
You can also work in PS with green /blue screens but you have to now how to make decontamination of green color cast.

Best

Apr 24 16 10:22 am Link

Photographer

Kent Art Photography

Posts: 3588

Ashford, England, United Kingdom

ST Retouch wrote:
For professional photography and real composite work , forget any green/screen backgrounds or any chroma key software.

Green/Blue Screen is for video composite work .
Even in video composite work chroma key  is just a basic step for extraction,  for top results later you have to work rotoscoping very often frame by frame.

For image composite work white/grey background  is industry standard .
Chroma key software with sliders and green/blue screen backgrounds is for quick amateurish results with tons of halo edges and problematic colors cast around, with some file maybe you can get some decent results with low res images but for serious results no.

If you want to  learn composite work - Photoshop only and white/grey backgrounds .
You can also work in PS with green /blue screens but you have to now how to make decontamination of green color cast.

Best

This.

Apr 24 16 12:15 pm Link

Retoucher

3869283

Posts: 1464

Sofia, Sofija grad, Bulgaria

Take a look into the future:

https://lytro.com/cinema

Apr 24 16 12:42 pm Link

Photographer

Kent Art Photography

Posts: 3588

Ashford, England, United Kingdom

anchev wrote:
Take a look into the future:

https://lytro.com/cinema

Yes, fine for moving pictures.  I don't understand how anyone would use green screen for stills, though.

Apr 24 16 01:46 pm Link

Retoucher

3869283

Posts: 1464

Sofia, Sofija grad, Bulgaria

Kent Art Photography wrote:
Yes, fine for moving pictures.

Moving pictures = sequence of still pictures.
Light field camera is a technology which covers both.

I don't understand how anyone would use green screen for stills, though.

It depends on the purpose.

I use chroma blue background a lot because cyan is the opposite of skin in color space and gives me the possibility to change its hue in post. I don't use it for alpha channel creation. For best quality in photo compositing the background color and light should be in sync with the planned replacement and the target look.

Apr 24 16 02:39 pm Link

Retoucher

ST Retouch

Posts: 393

Amsterdam, Noord-Holland, Netherlands

anchev wrote:
Take a look into the future:

https://lytro.com/cinema

Anchev, thank you for link.

I have never hear about this web site, it looks promising but I could not find where I can see trial version or this project is not finished yet?

Yes I can see in video that you can change background in video post production without to have green/blue screen but with this simple video with half body shot you can make very easy extraction in After Effect also with their new video refine edge tool technology.
I am wondering how it will work with real complex video where you have full body shots with shadows on the ground ,  with moving pictures , with fast movements , where we have problematic blur effects on skin edges in video and more complex background behind models.

Is there any trial version where we can see what works in reality?
Did you try that?

Thank you
Best

Apr 24 16 03:26 pm Link

Retoucher

3869283

Posts: 1464

Sofia, Sofija grad, Bulgaria

ST Retouch wrote:
Anchev, thank you for link.

I have never hear about this web site, it looks promising but I could not find where I can see trial version or this project is not finished yet?

Yes I can see in video that you can change background in video post production without to have green/blue screen but with this simple video with half body shot you can make very easy extraction in After Effect also with their new video refine edge tool technology.
I am wondering how it will work with real complex video where you have full body shots with shadows on the ground ,  with moving pictures , with fast movements , where we have problematic blur effects on skin edges in video and more complex background behind models.

Is there any trial version where we can see what works in reality?
Did you try that?

Thank you
Best

Hi,

How come you have not heard of Lytro? It has been around for some years. smile They actually started with consumer end light field camera (https://lytro.com/imaging) and just recently made this for cinema and announced that they will mostly work in the top pro market.

It is not really something "to try" because this is hardware, very expensive one (755 mpx, 300 fps, 16 stops of DR....). It is a new cinema camera which works with light fields and thus records actual 3D spatial data. That's why you don't need any particular background to do compositing. In that sense you don't really need any key-ing (be it chroma, luma or motion based) - you already have the depth data and that is the best quality. Just like rendering a 3D model over a background but in this case the 3D model is photographed, i.e. already rendered.

If you want to try something in this direction you can probably by the Lytro ILLUM and play with it as you really need the hardware to record the light field. But it is quite a low resolution camera for the moment, so still not very tempting.

Apr 25 16 01:26 am Link

Photographer

Giacomo Cirrincioni

Posts: 22234

Stamford, Connecticut, US

Kent Art Photography wrote:
Yes, fine for moving pictures.  I don't understand how anyone would use green screen for stills, though.

Green screen works fine if you have enough space so that there is no spill - if there is spill (which most here will face) it's a nightmare.  If you have a good 12 feet or more between your subject and the background, and you light it properly, green screen is very easy to work with.

I shoot for composite on a middle grey background, however, I sometimes change this up depending on the plan for the final image.  So, for example, if the subject is going to be composited against a red wall in an existing background plate, I might shoot the talent against a similar red.

Apr 25 16 07:31 am Link

Photographer

Abbitt Photography

Posts: 13564

Washington, Utah, US

I've done some green screen. With proper technique one can reduce any green fringing to a point it won't be noticeable even if superimposed on a white background. Minor blue fringing is much less noticeable against most new backgrounds than green is, so consider using that instead. The problem is blue clothing is much more common than green.  You'll also have to mask a model's eyes if they are blue, or you see the background through her eyes which is kind of creepy.

I would agree that learning to extract from a white background in photoshop is probably a good skill t have, but having an instant software extraction has it's place.

Apr 25 16 07:58 am Link

Photographer

Light and Lens Studio

Posts: 3450

Sisters, Oregon, US

Giacomo Cirrincioni wrote:

Green screen works fine if you have enough space so that there is no spill - if there is spill (which most here will face) it's a nightmare.  If you have a good 12 feet or more between your subject and the background, and you light it properly, green screen is very easy to work with.

I shoot for composite on a middle grey background, however, I sometimes change this up depending on the plan for the final image.  So, for example, if the subject is going to be composited against a red wall in an existing background plate, I might shoot the talent against a similar red.

You can kill green spill by using a magenta filter on a light that shines on the model's hair and shoulders

Apr 25 16 09:12 am Link

Photographer

Giacomo Cirrincioni

Posts: 22234

Stamford, Connecticut, US

Light and Lens Studio wrote:

You can kill green spill by using a magenta filter on a light that shines on the model's hair and shoulders

In theory yes, the colors cancel each other.  In practice in anything other than the  most controlled still life, you'll wind up with magenta spill that then has to be dealt with.  Personally, I'd rather deal with the green contamination in post.

Again, I prefer shooting on middle grey.

Apr 25 16 09:29 am Link

Photographer

J O H N A L L A N

Posts: 12221

Los Angeles, California, US

Light and Lens Studio wrote:

You can kill green spill by using a magenta filter on a light that shines on the model's hair and shoulders

I don't really do compositing - but from purely a lighting perspective I would not want to deal with the headache of this approach with partially crossing casts.

Apr 25 16 01:46 pm Link

Photographer

TMA Photo and Training

Posts: 1009

Lancaster, Pennsylvania, US

For the OP...the Color... or the Kind of material you use... is only part of the keying formula.

Here are 6 general guidelines for Chroma Keying that most commercial studios will keep in mind when setting up for a shoot.   Apologies for the length.

1. The Color.   Use the highly saturated and bright industry standard Chroma Key Green or Blue for the easiest way to get good results quickly.  People in the industry have spent years fine tuning those special colors.  If you have a robust keying program... then you could also possibly use a Light Battleship Gray color as the keying color in the studio.  I use the $89 Fluid Mask program and a gray screen in my studio to get single hair strand precision much of the time.  Fluid Mask is able to cut with ANY color...  as long as the background is not too overly complex.  If you are just starting out... or are doing a commercial job...then the specific ChromaKey Blue and Green colors and values are highly recommended.

2. Even Background Lighting.   Keep the background evenly lit from top to bottom and from left to right.  Diffused broad softbox kind of light from both the left and right sides is fairly good.  If you use fabric...make sure you can stretch it so you dont have any wrinkles that wont key out well.  Love using seamless background paper because it is easy to hang smoothly and it takes light well.  Painted flats work well too.  The key to good Chroma Keying is to get your background evenly and broadly lit with no wrinkles or shadows behind your talent.

3. The Cutting Program.   The program you use to cut with is very important for great results.  Some of the free programs dont cut anything but green or blue.  The inexpensive programs can sometimes cut other colors...  and some of them allow you to repair shadows or other problems with the background. (Big Help). The more expensive programs can cut any color,  they can mask out bad places in your background,  they can clean up the masks real well after the fact,  they have tools to reduce spill or contamination, they have the ability to optimize the mask in many ways,  and they are able to resolve even single wisps of hair accurately... if... the edges of your hair are against a smooth background, with a strong contrasting color,  that is properly lit, with no complexity at the edges.

4. The Model Distance.   Move your model at least 6-8 feet out in front of your green screen.  Many people "Way Over Light" and even flood the background with over brightness.  This causes a reverse bounce of bright green light to come back onto your model.  This ruins the edges with false information.  Use a light meter for measuring the background illumination... make sure the exposure is not more than 1 F stop above your main key light reading.   Magenta is the opposite of green... yellow is the opposite of blue... you can sometimes use a small hair light with a 1/2 strength gel to neutralize the contamination in the body edges or hair.  Remember: The further the model is away from the background...and the better the background brightness is under control...the more you wont have to worry about bad edges from contamination.

5. Kinds of Hair + Complexity.   For me black hair is fairly easy to cut accurately because it has good contrast with the background.  Dark Brown hair cuts really well for me.  Reddish or purple hair cuts out fairly well.  Blond hair IS TERRIBLE to cut out.  Blond hair is sometimes translucent or even almost clear...the green background light shows right through the strands...  and makes it almost impossible for the program to tell if the hair is blond or green... often it actually does look green... because blond hair picks up contamination colors real easily.  I almost never use a hair light on a blond im cutting...the light makes the strands become several shades of blond...and that really confuses the program further.  Put your hair shine in at the post production stage.

6. Masking Tools Inside Photoshop.   In Photoshop... under the Main Menu > Layer > Matting... there are 4 special masking tools that will help remove some of the ugly, tell tale white or black outlining in your hair or body cutouts.  They work real well. 

There is also a Defringe Tool and a De-Contaminate function at that same location that is also really helpful in cleaning up tough masks. 

There are also "Refine Edge" tools in the Photoshop Properties dialogue... that can be used to refine your mask for better results.  There are about 5 functions that can be used to help make your cutout look better in there. 

You can also use the "dodge and burn tools" on just your Mask Only...  to make some light areas lighter or some dark areas darker... or vise versa...this gives your mask more resolving power and you can control where it happens.  Dodging and burning the cutout mask can sometimes make a very significant enhancement in your final end results.

OP...Good luck in your green screen journey!   When I remember to address all of these elements in my green screen sessions... I can usually get single strands of hair to cutout cleanly without any artifacts. 
Its amazing when everything comes together well !

Apr 25 16 03:21 pm Link