Photographer
Garry k
Posts: 30131
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Heidi vs Claudia - who was the top "Uber "Model in their prime ( please don't answer Naomi Campbell - thsi is not about supermodels in general )
Photographer
TREVOR GODINHO
Posts: 365
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Heidi Klum ... hands down .. any time of the day .. she amazin ...
Photographer
Star
Posts: 17966
Los Angeles, California, US
Aren't they the same person?
Photographer
udor
Posts: 25255
New York, New York, US
Garry k wrote:
Heidi vs Claudia - who was the top "Uber "Model in their prime This is actually an interesting question.
If we are talking about actual "supermodels" then Claudia Schiffer takes the crown, since she was always a high fashionmodel working for some of the top designers in the world including Chanel.
She was also internationally well known.
Heidi Klum is really more a "regional" supermodel, who is most famous in the United States because of Swimsuit Illustrated and Victoria Secret, and for her endeavours in television, most recently "Project Runway".
Karl Lagerfeld was interviewed in Germany a few months ago, maybe last year, and during the interview he was asked what he thinks about Heidi Klum... and he was drawing a blank, because he had never heard of her.
That said, I have no experience on a "personal level" with Claudia, but had interaction with Heidi and saw her last at the taping of the final show of "Project Runway" at the Olympus Fashionweek. And from all I can tell, and also the interviews I saw with Heidi is that she is a doll... extremely charming and lighthearted person.
I like her a lot and I think she looks much cuter, but she never had the supermodel status that Claudia Schiffer had.
Photographer
B R E E D L O V E
Posts: 8022
Forks, Washington, US
Heidi because besides being beautiful I just love her sense of humor and fun attitude.
Photographer
C R Photography
Posts: 3594
Pleasanton, California, US
Coke Head = Heidi vs. Gold Digger = Claudia I'll take the gold digger 
Model
Renee Hyde
Posts: 178
New York, New York, US
I would have to say Claudia. I think she's more well known like the others are saying, but personally, I'd kill to look like Claudia, but I wouldn't want to look like Heidi, but that's just me.
Model
Constance Hilory
Posts: 1706
Mobile, Alabama, US
My vote is Claudia Schiffer because she is known throughout the world.
Photographer
Tamara Fiset
Posts: 235
Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Model
Mayanlee
Posts: 3560
New City, New York, US
Claudia.
But I still think Linda Evangelista or Cristy Turlington trumps both of 'em...
Model
na52
Posts: 344
Terry Breedlove wrote:
Heidi because besides being beautiful I just love her sense of humor and fun attitude. I 2nd that
Model
_ALMUR_
Posts: 3153
San Francisco, California, US
claudia is the prettyist woman in the world. i would vote for her, then tell my friends to vote fro her, then campain for her, then become president to.... well you get the picture.
Photographer
udor
Posts: 25255
New York, New York, US
Alexandria M. wrote:
claudia is the prettyist woman in the world. i would vote for her, then tell my friends to vote fro her, then campain for her, then become president to.... well you get the picture. So... do you like Claudia or not?
Model
Courtney P
Posts: 46
Athens, Alabama, US
My opinion would be Heidi. She is very beautiful, great body, and seems to be fun to be around, which is always good. She doesn't seem stuck-up or anything. Of course I've never met her in person, so...who knows.
Photographer
photoego
Posts: 28
South Middletown, Ohio, US
I think Heidi..plus I've met her and she's a sweetheart.  Rob
Model
na52
Posts: 344
photoego wrote:
I think Heidi..plus I've met her and she's a sweetheart.
Rob lucky ducky
Model
na52
Posts: 344
here is a visual Claudia ![https://art.allayers.com/images/large/claudia_schiffer_by_herb_ritts.jpg]() Hedi ![https://hklum.home.att.net/swimsuit/original/sw126.jpg]() could be sisters...lol
Photographer
B R E E D L O V E
Posts: 8022
Forks, Washington, US
uhm now I am thinking why just one I want both can you say threesome.
Photographer
Pacific Beach Pictures
Posts: 112
Love, Saskatchewan, Canada
Claudia vs. Heidi in a no holds barred 14' steel cage match to the finish. It's a submission match too, none of this three count sh**. ;P
Photographer
Garry k
Posts: 30131
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
C R Photography wrote:
Coke Head = Heidi
vs.
Gold Digger = Claudia
I'll take the gold digger Those are some pretty strong accusations ?????
Photographer
Garry k
Posts: 30131
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
ericphotonyc wrote:
Matthew Vaughn vs. Seal No contest there ....
Photographer
Hamza
Posts: 7791
New York, New York, US
Having worked with both Claudia and Heidi(Fashion Cafe, Victoria's Secret/7th on 6th), I would have to say Claudia because of her "Presence" when she walks into a room. Heidi is cool as hell, but she doesn't command the attention when walking into a room like Claudia. When Heidi walked on set, she was all friendly and cool and greeted everyone. When Claudia walked on set, the room was silenced! Everyone stopped whatever they were doing and acknowledged her existance...
Heidi is your friend you wish you had benefits with, Claudia is the woman of your dreams...
Photographer
SLE Photography
Posts: 68937
Orlando, Florida, US
Mayanlee wrote:
Claudia.
But I still think Linda Evangelista or Cristy Turlington trumps both of 'em... Yes, and both of them (and Heidi as well) show b(0)(0)bies, whereas Cladia is just a prude.
Photographer
SLE Photography
Posts: 68937
Orlando, Florida, US
Pacific Beach Pictures wrote:
Claudia vs. Heidi in a no holds barred 14' steel cage match to the finish. It's a submission match too, none of this three count sh**. ;P No, we need a WWE style Lingerie Pillow Fight, winner strips loser.
Photographer
Garry k
Posts: 30131
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Hamza wrote:
Having worked with both Claudia and Heidi(Fashion Cafe, Victoria's Secret/7th on 6th), I would have to say Claudia because of her "Presence" when she walks into a room. Heidi is cool as hell, but she doesn't command the attention when walking into a room like Claudia. When Heidi walked on set, she was all friendly and cool and greeted everyone. When Claudia walked on set, the room was silenced! Everyone stopped whatever they were doing and acknowledged her existance...
Heidi is your friend you wish you had benefits with, Claudia is the woman of your dreams... Very well stated
Model
Ashley Deal
Posts: 26
Jacksonville, Florida, US
Heidi has such natural beauty and Claudia seems to only look good when her eyes are masked with dark make up in my opinion.
Photographer
Garry k
Posts: 30131
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Ashley Spicer wrote:
Heidi has such natural beauty and Claudia seems to only look good when her eyes are masked with dark make up in my opinion. ?
Model
YummyGirl
Posts: 20
Milwaukee, Wisconsin, US
Partial to Heidi .. she's my baby dohl. Been one of my favs ever since I had interest in modeling
Photographer
La Seine by the Hudson
Posts: 8587
New York, New York, US
Mayanlee wrote:
Claudia.
But I still think Linda Evangelista or Cristy Turlington trumps both of 'em... Yup. My thoughts precisely.
Photographer
Garry k
Posts: 30131
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Marko Cecic-Karuzic wrote:
Yup. My thoughts precisely. See my forum discussion - Why Naomi Campbell is the #1 Supermodel of all time ?
I matched Heidi and Claudia agianst each other because they are both German and built like Panzer tanks
Model
Mayanlee
Posts: 3560
New City, New York, US
Marko Cecic-Karuzic wrote:
Yup. My thoughts precisely. Let me also throw Iman in with that list. I know I'm going off-topic and that the OP had a specific criteria in mind, but if you made that contest between Iman and Naomi, I'll take Iman every time.
Maybe I'm just too old-school...
Photographer
Garry k
Posts: 30131
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Mayanlee wrote:
Let me also throw Iman in with that list. I know I'm going off-topic and that the OP had a specific criteria in mind, but if you made that contest between Iman and Naomi, I'll take Iman every time.
Maybe I'm just too old-school... Ok lets do that then - Naomi vs Iman ( wiithout her implants ) I will start a new discussion
Photographer
C R Photography
Posts: 3594
Pleasanton, California, US
Garry k wrote:
Those are some pretty strong accusations ????? Is that a question?
These are not accusations, these are facts.
In Heidi's hay-day she was busted at Heathrow with .5 grams of cocaine in her purse (mid 90's).
Claudia just married a close (but not close enough) heir to the throne of some country.
Might wanna read-up prior to asking redundant questions
Photographer
Garry k
Posts: 30131
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
C R Photography wrote:
Is that a question?
These are not accusations, these are facts.
In Heidi's hay-day she was busted at Heathrow with .5 grams of cocaine in her purse (mid 90's).
Claudia just married a close (but not close enough) heir to the throne of some country.
Might wanna read-up prior to asking redundant questions Hey you got me - I tend not to read that much or watch tv preferring to live the life - not sample the soundbites
My guess is that like many of us - as a young man you probably smoked a little grass /weed /herb ( maybe you still do ) Does that make you a "pothead "
And in your experience - do you know any woman who would marry a poor guy over a rich one ( everything else being equal )
Photographer
udor
Posts: 25255
New York, New York, US
C R Photography wrote:
Is that a question?
These are not accusations, these are facts.
In Heidi's hay-day she was busted at Heathrow with .5 grams of cocaine in her purse (mid 90's).
Claudia just married a close (but not close enough) heir to the throne of some country.
Might wanna read-up prior to asking redundant questions Many top models, with lotsa money did coke in the 90's... wanna guess if Claudia powderd her nose too?
Re: Golddigger... the guy is RELATED to line of counts, but he is NOT in the lineup for a title, EDIT: as explained in the Wikipedia article below... so... she certainly is not oogling at a throne!
Claudia Schiffer
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claudia_Schiffer
[...]On May 25, 2002 she married film producer Matthew de Vere Drummond, born as Matthew Vaughn, son of George Albert Harley Drummond (also known as George de Vere Drummond).
It was widely reported at the time of Claudia Schiffer's marriage that one day she could become the Countess of Oxford because her father-in-law was in line of succession to the Earldom of Oxford and Mortimer. She is disqualified on two counts: Matthew's illegitimacy would bar him from any succession and George Harley Drummond is not in line for succession as he is not descended from the male line.
|
