Forums > Critique > Sugar-free critique.

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

I’m offering my serious critique/opinion of your work. I will not sugar-coat things; I’m going to tell you exactly what I think of your portfolio and profile.

PS. I hate fake blood and props... if either are in your port don’t expect much. I also HAAAAATE duckfaces and cellphone mirror shots, don't bother ask for a critique if you have them.

Aug 01 12 06:32 pm Link

Photographer

Paul Tirado Photography

Posts: 4363

New York, New York, US

Take a look and let me know. Thank you for your time and opinion.

Aug 01 12 06:38 pm Link

Photographer

Jeff Fiore

Posts: 9225

Brooklyn, New York, US

OK, I'm in.

Aug 01 12 06:39 pm Link

Model

Cole Morrison

Posts: 3958

Portland, Oregon, US

ok

Aug 01 12 06:44 pm Link

Photographer

Fotografica Gregor

Posts: 4126

Alexandria, Virginia, US

Please feel free - always desire input that can help me see my blind spots and grow.

Aug 01 12 06:48 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Paul Tirado Photography wrote:
Take a look and let me know. Thank you for your time and opinion.

For the most part your portfolio is clean and consistent. Your studio work is strong, I would be very confident in hiring you for a studio shoot.

This shot throws your port off IMO... it's dull, soft focus, lots of distraction in the background.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/080413/01/4801a05a9f1be_m.jpg

Same goes with this shot, distracting background.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120722/17/500ca0ce9693c_m.jpg

Overall your studio work is good, but your portfolio seems stretched with a few weak images. 30 of your best shots could create an incredibly strong port.

Aug 01 12 06:53 pm Link

Model

GabrielleEC

Posts: 208

BOISE, Idaho, US

I would definitely love some serious critique

Aug 01 12 06:57 pm Link

Photographer

Red Baron Photography

Posts: 330

Montreal, Quebec, Canada

bring it on smile

Aug 01 12 07:05 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Jeff Fiore wrote:
OK, I'm in.

Interesting. Some of it is dirty, some of it is beautiful, some of it is boring, some of it is interesting. 95 pics is a lot, with at least half of them shot the same baisc way - hardwood floor, baseboard, wall, naked girl in front. It almost could be considered a style, but the consistency isn't there... it's kind of all over the place, especialy with the post work. It's hard to tell if the shots are a result of your vision or if you just tell let the model do their thing and you take their picture...

Aug 01 12 07:06 pm Link

Model

Candy Ma

Posts: 167

San Diego, California, US

Go for it.

Aug 01 12 07:19 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Cole Morrison wrote:
ok

This is awesome.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120323/02/4f6c45daef5fb_m.jpg

There isn't really anything I don't like about your portfolio. I think you have tons of potential with your art nudes, you have some great poses. I hope you keep going in that direction! The topless shot in the lake is my favourite for sure, awesome pose.

Aug 01 12 07:21 pm Link

Model

Zoe Chanel

Posts: 164

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Could you do me?

Aug 01 12 07:21 pm Link

Photographer

Jorge Kreimer

Posts: 3716

San Cristóbal de las Casas, Chiapas, Mexico

Sure, go ahead.

Aug 01 12 07:27 pm Link

Model

KCLynne

Posts: 466

Omaha, Nebraska, US

I'm game

Aug 01 12 07:35 pm Link

Model

Cole Morrison

Posts: 3958

Portland, Oregon, US

CRUIKSHANK PHOTOGRAPHY wrote:

This is awesome.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120323/02/4f6c45daef5fb_m.jpg

There isn't really anything I don't like about your portfolio. I think you have tons of potential with your art nudes, you have some great poses. I hope you keep going in that direction! The topless shot in the lake is my favourite for sure, awesome pose.

big_smile thanks! im glad to hear that.
it definitely is the direction i am going. im eagerly awaiting my next nude set for my portfolio.

Aug 01 12 07:37 pm Link

Model

Miss Bond

Posts: 1507

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

okii

Aug 01 12 07:41 pm Link

Model

Chloe Selene

Posts: 636

Albuquerque, New Mexico, US

I just added several new images so I'm very curious to hear some critique.  Thanks in advance. smile

Aug 01 12 07:46 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Fotografica Gregor wrote:
Please feel free - always desire input that can help me see my blind spots and grow.

Your profile is well written; very professional. Your portfolio is kind of scattered though and does not give off the same professional vibe.  First of all there are too many pictures.

You have 12 pictures (or close to it) shot at the location with brick walls and hardwood floors scattered throughout your portfolio (very cool spot by the way). I think if you cut that down to 8, and organized them in two rows grouped together they would display nicer.

If you organized your portfolio like you organized your profile the overall impact of your work would be much stronger.

Aug 01 12 07:46 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

GabrielleEC wrote:
I would definitely love some serious critique

I like your first 5 pictures along with these:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120621/04/4fe30654a8cf3_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120620/00/4fe1765047efb_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120531/05/4fc75ea8bfbaa_m.jpg

They display some pretty awesome posing capability, along with a variety unique creative concepts.

The others suffer from flat lighting, poor post work (zebra mask shot), poor composition, distracting background (shot with knife), harsh lighting (lightning bolt earing), and so on.

The 8 shots I mentioned above are on a different level than the others.

Aug 01 12 08:00 pm Link

Photographer

David Desoer

Posts: 148

Cayuga, Ontario, Canada

Aug 01 12 08:02 pm Link

Model

GabrielleEC

Posts: 208

BOISE, Idaho, US

CRUIKSHANK PHOTOGRAPHY wrote:

I like your first 5 pictures along with these:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120621/04/4fe30654a8cf3_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120620/00/4fe1765047efb_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120531/05/4fc75ea8bfbaa_m.jpg

They display some pretty awesome posing capability, along with a variety unique creative concepts.

The others suffer from flat lighting, poor post work (zebra mask shot), poor composition, distracting background (shot with knife), harsh lighting (lightning bolt earing), and so on.

The 8 shots I mentioned above are on a different level than the others.

Cannot say thanks enough for the critique!

Aug 01 12 08:03 pm Link

Model

Alex Cupcakee

Posts: 38

Miami, Florida, US

Pretty new i love any feedback thanks!!

Aug 01 12 08:05 pm Link

Photographer

Fotografica Gregor

Posts: 4126

Alexandria, Virginia, US

CRUIKSHANK PHOTOGRAPHY wrote:

Your profile is well written; very professional. Your portfolio is kind of scattered though and does not give off the same professional vibe.  First of all there are too many pictures.

You have 12 pictures (or close to it) shot at the location with brick walls and hardwood floors scattered throughout your portfolio (very cool spot by the way). I think if you cut that down to 8, and organized them in two rows grouped together they would display nicer.

If you organized your portfolio like you organized your profile the overall impact of your work would be much stronger.

Thank you for that input - I appreciate it very much. 

It has seemed natural to me to group images of a type in the past but that drew criticism.  Nonetheless I'm drawn to that approach and I appreciate your confirming my instinct on this.

And yes I do realize it's too many images smile   It is very hard for me to edit down - I tend to get attached to some of them - mostly for the models and their work.

Thank you again

Gregor

Aug 01 12 08:11 pm Link

Photographer

A N D E R S O N

Posts: 2553

Rockville, Maryland, US

Me please.

Aug 01 12 08:11 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Red Baron Photography wrote:
bring it on smile

The red wall worked, it provided a nice contrast it looks like you had some nice even light for those shots, no hot spots, not distractions in the backgrounds, shows potential for some quality glamour work.

Other than that I don't really find your work all that interesting.  I noticed you shoot down on your models a fair bit... extreme angles such as this will distort the model which is a bad thing, especially if it makes them look short and squashed.

Aug 01 12 08:13 pm Link

Photographer

Jeff Fiore

Posts: 9225

Brooklyn, New York, US

CRUIKSHANK PHOTOGRAPHY wrote:

Interesting. Some of it is dirty, some of it is beautiful, some of it is boring, some of it is interesting. 95 pics is a lot, with at least half of them shot the same baisc way - hardwood floor, baseboard, wall, naked girl in front. It almost could be considered a style, but the consistency isn't there... it's kind of all over the place, especialy with the post work. It's hard to tell if the shots are a result of your vision or if you just tell let the model do their thing and you take their picture...

Thank you!

Aug 01 12 08:14 pm Link

Photographer

David Scott

Posts: 5617

Marion, Iowa, US

sure

Aug 01 12 08:17 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Candy Ma  wrote:
Go for it.

Shoot more! Shoot more! Shoot more!

Sorry I can't say more based off two shoots. The poses aren't anything special. I have a list of awesome poses... I use it to help direct my models. Make a list similar and practice poses and expressions. A small portfolio is fine, but it has to be awesome! Show us your awesomeness!

Aug 01 12 08:21 pm Link

Photographer

Images by MR

Posts: 8908

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Shoot...

Aug 01 12 08:29 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

zoe chanel wrote:
Could you do me?

Ditch the grafitti shots... they are out of focus and a distracting background is a bad background. I made the mistake when I first started, did a shoot against grafitti because I thought it was cool... it very rarely works.

I love this, casual, beautiful, great hair
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120701/22/4ff13731ca04b_m.jpg

I think you could really benefit from a pro shoot. The soft shots are cool, but they don't give your portfolio the POP it needs to catch my attention. A good, clear, full length shot that shows off your figure would help out as well.

Aug 01 12 08:31 pm Link

Model

Constantia

Posts: 447

Santiago, Metropolitana, Chile

I would love to know, and if there are any that should go bye bye. Give it to me!

Aug 01 12 08:35 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Jorge Kreimer wrote:
Sure, go ahead.

Simple, natural, beautiful.

This is my favourite, it is awesome.
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/27172586

There is a quietness to your work that makes it special. No frills, no distractions.

Keep doing what you are doing because it's one of a kind and it's awesome.

Aug 01 12 08:44 pm Link

Model

Lori Cherkowski

Posts: 9

Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada

Would love some critique!!

Aug 01 12 08:50 pm Link

Photographer

Jay Dee-Foto

Posts: 56

New York, New York, US

sugar free is how i like it.

Aug 01 12 08:52 pm Link

Model

LittleMissVivacious

Posts: 198

Redding, California, US

I'd love some honest critique. smile

Aug 01 12 08:54 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

KCLynne wrote:
I'm game

Beautiful smile!
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120412/10/4f871771588f9_m.jpg

It's tough for me to critique you, because for the most part the shots in your port are more about the location. I'm all about cool locations, and wide artistic shots... but as a model you need some shots that focus on you. Get some tighter portrait shots in your portfolio and you will be rockin!

Aug 01 12 08:56 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Miss Bond wrote:
okii

Beautifu, classy, professional.
Your portfolio shows a variety of poses and looks.
It's pretty much perfect.
You deserve to be paid top dollar for your work.
Rookie models should take a look at your work becuase you obviously know how it's done.

Aug 01 12 09:02 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Done for now... I'll be back!

Aug 01 12 09:16 pm Link

Photographer

Andrea Cronshaw

Posts: 406

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Well there is one photo with a bit of fake blood in my portfolio so I don't know what you'll think of me, but I'm still interested to hear it.

Aug 01 12 09:19 pm Link

Model

Emily Smiles

Posts: 295

Columbia, South Carolina, US

Please let me know!!

Thanks!

Aug 01 12 09:20 pm Link