Forums > Critique > Serious Critique > Would like some critique on my portfolio

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Is there things I need to change? Am I on the right track?

Apr 01 16 01:06 pm Link

Photographer

AJ_In_Atlanta

Posts: 13053

Atlanta, Georgia, US

You are on the right track, but reduce the duplicates especially the ones with the same expression.  Quality over Quantity and Diversity over Repetition.

Apr 01 16 01:18 pm Link

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Thank you. I appreciate it. I removed some

Apr 01 16 03:11 pm Link

Model

Phenomabomb

Posts: 1

Huntsville, Alabama, US

Perfecto

Apr 01 16 08:13 pm Link

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Thank you

Apr 01 16 08:34 pm Link

Photographer

Orca Bay Images

Posts: 33877

Arcata, California, US

You've got a fantastic look and your portfolio is very impressive. However, you've got a few lackluster images that don't do you justice.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160203/12/56b2636662d88_m.jpg
IMO, the weakest image. The wardrobe and the pose don't show you off well. It doesn't even show off the wardrobe well. And your nose is casting a hard shadow on your cheek.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/151228/15/5681c6ad662d2_m.jpg
You're buried in the layers of heavy clothes, but there's that sweet face. The image has a sweet innocence about it, but it's still weaker than most of your portfolio.

Apr 02 16 08:11 am Link

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Thank you so much. I appreciate it!

Apr 02 16 08:20 am Link

Photographer

Shadow Dancer

Posts: 9777

Bellingham, Washington, US

You are off to a fantastic start, way above average.

Others have mentioned quality before quantity, I agree as you have many photos to choose from.

Try this, over the next few days pick your 10 favorite photos in your port.

Then, clear your mind and pick the 10 that you think best represent you as a Model to potential clients.

Do they match up? Whether they match up or not, try building your quality port from those 20 images.

In any case, I would delete the following image. You look wonderful but your garment is a bit tatty looking overall. The sign running into your forehead is distracting also.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150925/18/5605f3a6312e0.jpg

Apr 02 16 11:24 am Link

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Thank you for your wonderful advice. I might have a hard time picking my fav 10 smile but I'll work on it.

Apr 02 16 12:00 pm Link

Photographer

Larry Sparks Photo

Posts: 30

Cape Town, Western Cape, South Africa

Cant find any fault here :-)

Apr 08 16 04:57 am Link

Photographer

Ike Lace Photography

Posts: 159

Chicago, Illinois, US

No there "isn't" things you need to change.

Cull your boring ones.

Apr 09 16 12:26 am Link

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Thanks for the feedback smile

Apr 09 16 09:12 am Link

Photographer

Orca Bay Images

Posts: 33877

Arcata, California, US

Ike Lace Photography wrote:
No there "isn't" things you need to change.

Cull your boring ones.

And which, in your sketchy opinion, are the boring ones?

Have you ever provided any positive feedback, Ike? Have you ever provided any detailed feedback?  Is the best you can do just a snarky bit of grammar Naziism?

Please consider ceasing your "critiques."

Apr 09 16 12:58 pm Link

Photographer

Orca Bay Images

Posts: 33877

Arcata, California, US

One more thing, Madison... One thing you could add more of: range of expression.

You're drop-dead lovely, but a greater range of expression would knock that great portfolio into orbit. You do the pensive looks wonderfully...
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160328/19/56f9e9279e2ff_m.jpg

But there's only one image of you looking like you're having fun...
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150804/07/55c0c9a7bb69d_m.jpg
The smile looks a bit forced, but IMO it's still a wonderful change of pace and shows another side of you.

I'd love to see you try looks such as: vampy, trashy, rotten attitude, playful, quizzical, caught off-guard, etc.

Apr 09 16 01:17 pm Link

Photographer

DespayreFX

Posts: 1481

Delta, British Columbia, Canada

You might want to start creating albums for your port images, separating by category. I'd include a separate one for tearsheets too.

Apr 10 16 04:47 pm Link

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Thank you. That's great advice

Apr 10 16 05:31 pm Link

Photographer

DespayreFX

Posts: 1481

Delta, British Columbia, Canada

Madison Mayne wrote:
Thank you. That's great advice

It's almost like I know stuff... wink

Apr 11 16 08:47 am Link

Photographer

Lee_Photography

Posts: 9863

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160406/20/5705d527be55f_m.jpg
You are a beautiful woman
For me this photo tells a story

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160327/12/56f8333c9111b_m.jpg
You have several photos that are over the top, like this one
Those eyes are fantastic

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150814/10/55ce259d67838_m.jpg
Again, your eyes are off the charts

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160327/12/56f83332c1866_m.jpg
You have the ability to create many different looks


I would thin down your port by eliminating any photos that are similar

I wish you well

Apr 16 16 05:07 am Link

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Thank you. i appreciate it

Apr 16 16 10:30 am Link

Photographer

KungPaoChic

Posts: 4221

West Palm Beach, Florida, US

You are a gorgeous girl and you have some very nice images in your portfolio.

IMO some of your images look a tad overprocessed which it doesn't look like you need ( it looks like you have good skin).

If you are wanting to work commercially you might want to add more images with realistic looking skin.

Apr 30 16 05:02 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30129

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

First of all -let me say that You are a Great Model to work with

I think your portfolio would benifit from a couple of things

a few beauty shots with some hair and makeup variations ( including an up do )

and at least 1 Runway shot - cus you do that well too

smile

Apr 30 16 07:25 pm Link

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Thank you for the help. I appreciate it!

May 01 16 12:13 pm Link

Photographer

thiswayup

Posts: 1136

Runcorn, England, United Kingdom

Orca Bay Images wrote:
You've got a fantastic look and your portfolio is very impressive. However, you've got a few lackluster images that don't do you justice.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160203/12/56b2636662d88_m.jpg
IMO, the weakest image. The wardrobe and the pose don't show you off well. It doesn't even show off the wardrobe well. And your nose is casting a hard shadow on your cheek.

I'd have kept this pose. Have you ever asked a model to look disinterested while remaining attractive and charismatic? It's VERY hard to pull off - it's one of the things that only top of the line talent can do. It's one of those things you see in big budget shoots that you have to learn to avoid on a lesser budget - like those perfect zoom shots you imagine using in your own videos, which turn out to need a whole camera crew to work properly. I'd be inclined to believe a model who can do this can do anything.

The hard shadow is a few seconds in post to remove.

Edited to add: I just spent two hours on a UK forum looking for a model in my area whose port had an image showing posing ability on the level this shot shows. Not every photographer looks at every shot on the basis of how hot the model is; I think those of who want acting ability and subtlety as well as range would be impressed by this shot!

May 01 16 02:07 pm Link

Model

Madison Mayne

Posts: 35

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Thank you for your feedback. I have added the photo back into my port smile

May 20 16 07:12 pm Link

Photographer

Paul Ferris

Posts: 3625

New York, New York, US

You have a port that is diverse in outfits, in settings, in poses and in photographer styles. Sadly you have the same facial expression in almost every photo in your port.  SHAKE THINGS UP!!!  Have fun! Stick out your tongue! Smile! Laugh!! Cross your eyes! Add some diversity to your port and it will go a long long way.

Feb 21 24 09:05 pm Link