Forums > Digital Art and Retouching > DAR Critiques > How would YOU improve these pictures?

Photographer

Zhiffy Photography

Posts: 1134

Singapore, Singapore, Singapore

I've these 2 photos that I've taken and retouched, but I'm still not fully satisfied with them.
Any ideas how to give them the extra oomph? (:

https://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash1/hs535.ash1/31343_409245023456_665328456_4373097_5827829_n.jpg
https://i14.photobucket.com/albums/a326/chocolatepiggy/DSC_0736r.jpg

May 28 10 02:28 am Link

Photographer

B R U N E S C I

Posts: 25319

Bath, England, United Kingdom

Dodge & burn wink



Just my $0.02

Ciao
Stefano

www.stefanobrunesci.com

May 28 10 02:44 am Link

Photographer

Narciscus Studio

Posts: 2012

Durban, KwaZulu Natal, South Africa

Cool shots smile
Top one I could suggest removing the flyaway's from the front of her head. Perhaps on the left of her hair, you could add more, so there were no areas you could see the floor. IMHO adding this sort of volume, plus it coming in from left may draw the viewers eye in toward the face.

2'nd image (and please mind this is just something I would do) Id remove the tattoo off the arm. The reason being that its not completely visible, therefore doesnt add to the shot.

May 28 10 02:48 am Link

Retoucher

FLEXmero

Posts: 1001

Madrid, Madrid, Spain

The second one has serious skin tone and exposure issues. Skin tone is not even. There are some grays (that next to the reds look blue, as if you could see her veins) The hair is, imho, very underexposed and lacking detail. How many exposures did you make?

May 28 10 02:57 am Link

Retoucher

FLEXmero

Posts: 1001

Madrid, Madrid, Spain

sorry, double post (hardware problems)

May 28 10 02:57 am Link

Model

Ashley N C

Posts: 2

Kapaa, Hawaii, US

May 28 10 04:07 am Link

Digital Artist

Koray

Posts: 6720

Ankara, Ankara, Turkey

FLEXmanta wrote:
The second one has serious skin tone and exposure issues. Skin tone is not even. There are some grays (that next to the reds look blue, as if you could see her veins) The hair is, imho, very underexposed and lacking detail.

I agree there are some serious issues about the 2nd one mostly mentioned above.

May 28 10 04:32 am Link

Retoucher

Teodor Sirbu

Posts: 197

Iaşi, Iaşi, Romania

to me the first one looks too flat

May 28 10 07:58 am Link

Retoucher

y2cute

Posts: 267

San Francisco, California, US

really like the first one, but minor stuffs like removing flyaway hairs and matching the background (small portions on the left corner still look green...probably need to be white).

May 28 10 10:39 am Link

Photographer

Zhiffy Photography

Posts: 1134

Singapore, Singapore, Singapore

Thanks for all your replies guys! Am working on them.

This is my 2nd photo now:
https://i14.photobucket.com/albums/a326/chocolatepiggy/DSC_0736r1.jpg

May 28 10 11:32 am Link

Retoucher

KKP Retouching

Posts: 1489

Anaheim, California, US

^ I like the first version you posted better.  It looks like you punched the contrast on her skin and part of her hair, and lowered it on the rest... and the opposite needs to happen.

Also... is her hair supposed to have green and blue in it?

May 31 10 12:04 am Link

Photographer

Narciscus Studio

Posts: 2012

Durban, KwaZulu Natal, South Africa

Zhiffy Photography wrote:
Thanks for all your replies guys! Am working on them.

Good job on pushing the fill light on the hair, and balancing of the skin tones.

May 31 10 05:28 am Link

Photographer

Miss Lexi Photo

Posts: 56

Townsville, Queensland, Australia

On the second version you posted...there seems to be a red stripe running vertically through her hair (in the middle of the picture).. The hair here doesn't match. Also, I'd add a little more interest to the hair on the left (her right)...And fix the tones within the hair.

Her hand could use some more work.

The skin is looking a lot better, however I think you could do a little more D&B work to smooth it out a bit. Also, the shadows are a little chunky (mostly on the neck, but some on the face and hand). I'd remove the unnecessary shadows, or at least even out the edges into the midtones so she doesn't look too lumpy.
Also, to me, the skin still looks a little too saturated and red. Maybe tone that down just a little bit? smile

I really love the first image smile I agree though, i'd add some more hair to the bulk of it behind her head, to cover the patches of floor smile

Jun 01 10 06:25 pm Link

Photographer

Bethany Souza

Posts: 1464

Pensacola, Florida, US

Not over expose.
Whats going on with the second pictures hair? Did you cut and paste hair from a bunch of other photos or something? The colors and texture dont match and they dont even look like they were taken with the same camera!

Jun 07 10 07:26 pm Link